Skip to content

Mayfair: A Modular Case Study


Previously used as a surface parking lot for commuters accessing public transit, the Mayfair development on a city-owned block in El Cerrito, Calif. brings 223 new housing units to a long-neglected stretch near the El Cerrito del Norte Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) Station.

The affordable and market-rate units will be in their own U-shaped buildings that surround a pair of open courtyards. The central open space between buildings will be open to the public during daylight hours to encourage activity in the transit-oriented development. 67 of the units will be classified as affordable housing, ranging in affordability from 30% – 60% of area median income.

The program mix between the two buildings consist of 10,500 sf of ground floor retail, parking, bicycle parking, property management, community rooms, dog wash and tenant service offices as amenities available for tenants. Program open space will include play areas, vegetable gardens, BBQ area and an outdoor kitchen.

Named for the grocery chain that once occupied the block, The Mayfair project received its first stacked module unit October 2020 and reached its full building height of six stories after ten days of assembly.

The modules for the 156-market rate units of the project started production in June 2019. The modules were fabricated by Factory_OS, only 19 miles away from the site in Vallejo, Calif.

Design Intent

This project sits on a dynamic site in terms of passers-by. It is located on a major thoroughfare (San Pablo Ave.), next door to the El Cerrito del Norte BART stop and regional transit hub. The building façade was envisioned to push the boundaries of modular design while creating a dynamic expression that could hold up to the power of the site. Responding to the movement of the BART trains, the design has horizontal undulating angles that stagger between floors, not common in modular construction.

Normally, a site bounded by heavy traffic and a major public transit line would seek to turn itself inward to protect against these challenges to living; however, the design instead opens toward the BART parking lot with a two-story portal that offers glimpses into the inner courtyard and puts the building’s common space on display for the neighborhood to see.

The plan was arranged with building circulation in a single loaded corridor on the exterior, where the façade faces the BART track. This serves as a sound buffer to the interior units and creates a mostly solid area of the façade that will have a large-scale public artwork facing BART.

Rounding out the aesthetics, the design team is working with a local artist on an installation incorporating areas of mirrored building skin that will blur and change daily for commuters on BART. The idea is that as the time of day and colors of sky change, the rider approach and experience of passing by the building will be unique.

Related Reading:
Modular Design Through the Construction Perspective

Unlike traditional, site-built projects, modular projects require a significant amount of up-front coordination, not just on design, but with project scheduling and factory bidding. This article explores how development teams will benefit from a deeper understanding of some of the contractor’s considerations unique to the modular approach.

Read the complete article


Modular Highlights

Initially, the Mayfair project was considered unbuildable as a modular project, given the complexity of exterior façade design. The architect and engineering team collaborated to figure out the best way to build the exterior envelope, which included the following challenges:

  • Articulation – Façade articulation was very important to this project. To break up the façade plane, the design was broken horizontally – an aesthetic element that contextually related to the nearby BART tracks and station. In achieving this, the placement of shear walls needed to be strategically coordinated with the structural engineer. With no repeating, stacking façade elements, the modular manufacturer had to be onboard to fabricate the building. The two-story, site-built portal design required coordination with the structural engineers and the factory to get the final installation to work.
  • Portal Design – The site-built portal is made up of both steel and wood framing construction. The design element is intended to activate the southern portion of building and support the modular units that sit above and adjacent to the opening. The coordination of steel placement was achieved with the help of a third-party clash detection agency, which was critical to overlay factory as-built conditions with site construction.
  • Single Loaded Corridor – The eastern portion of the building consists of a single loaded corridor. Though saw box units are generally not efficient in modular design, here, they allow the eastern corridor to face the street while the units face the courtyard – a move necessary to achieve the desired density of units. The single loaded corridor also allows for an acoustic buffer and provides space for innovative art panel installation at the eastern exterior wall.
  • Combination of Factory + Site Built for Common Rooms – Requested by planning to activate the façade, the common rooms were site built from structural steel, allowing for a greater span for programming including a lounge adjacent to the two-story portal and across from a fitness space.

Project Specifications

  • Type 3A Construction
  • Estimated completion: June 2021
  • Team:
    - Lowney Architects
    - DCI Engineers
    - FARD Engineers
    - Cannon Cononstructors
    - Factory_OS
    - Holliday Development

More from Modular Advantage

Roland Brown Looks Back at His Story of Success in the Modular Construction Industry

Roland Brown never imagined his life
would turn out this way. He retired from a nearly 50-year-long career, starting off as a draftsman in the mobile home industry to becoming the VP of Design and Development at Ramtech Building Systems, Inc., a design/build construction company in Mansfield, Texas with its own modular
manufacturing facility.

Welcoming the Industry’s Rising Stars to the World of Modular

As part of Tremco’s Rising Stars program, students from the East Career & Technical Academy attended World of Modular to learn from industry experts and meet representatives of companies from across the modular construction industry. Their instructor, Tremco’s David Hutchinson, led the morning-long program on the conference’s third day.

A Presidents’ Lunch 40 Years in the Making

At a luncheon hosted by MBI’s current executive director Tom Hardiman, CAE, and operations director Steven Williams, CAE, on the final day of the conference, nearly half of the association’s former board presidents were joined by Judy Smith, MBI’s former executive director who retired in 2004. There were warm greetings, old stories, and new insights into an
industry poised to grow like never before.

An Event to Remember: The 2023 World of Modular

MBI’s 2023 World of Modular conference and tradeshow was held in April at the luxurious Bellagio Resort & Hotel in Las Vegas, Nevada. World of Modular has long been the industry’s best chance to meet new contacts, learn from industry experts, and reconnect with old friends, but this year the excitement was palpable.

Mike Bollero, Sr.: A Leader in Modular Construction

Since those early days more than 50 years ago, Bollero has seen the modular construction industry grow and mature remarkably. The industry has provided both enduring relationships with colleagues as well as interesting challenges along the way. Here’s a look back at Mike Bollero, Sr.’s remarkable career.

European Company iQ Module Bets The Future on Shared Tech, Tools, and Partnerships

iQ Module—based out of Gdansk, Poland—has grown exponentially as a company, with offices in Germany and Denmark. The company has also embarked on an ongoing joint venture and partnership with Roger Krulak of FullStack Modular for projects in the U.S. and around the globe.

Modular Building is (Almost) as Old as the Hills

That modular building hasn’t already gained more U.S. market share is a source of bewilderment to many. Though the technology has been around for more than 70 years, modular building in the U.S. has never gained as solid a foothold as it has in other societies. But it’s time may finally be here.

Wilmot Modular: Always Willing to Help Out

Mike Wilmot, president of Wilmot Modular in Maryland, shares his experience responding to natural disasters and explains his company’s Rapid Response Program.

The Quick Response to Hurricane Katrina

Jane Conkin, owner of Quick Buildings Modular, recalls how her company provided much-needed modular buildings after Hurricane Katrina.

In Rough Times, Black Diamond Shines

Black Diamond CEO Trevor Haynes talks about the disasters his company has helped with and how disaster response is more than the “nuts and bolts” of transporting assets.