Making the Leap: From Traditional General Contractor to Modular Builder
The Modular Building Institute estimates there are about 250 modular manufacturers in North America accounting for slightly more than three percent of all new commercial construction starts. With the construction industry gaining momentum, traditional general contractors (GCs) are not finding the labor needed to meet demand.
That’s one reason we are seeing more traditional contractors making the leap and turning to modular construction. In some cases, GCs are contracting with modular manufacturers on “hybrid” projects that incorporate the best of modular and site-built processes. In other cases, contractors are establishing their own prefab divisions as a hedge against this labor shortage.
PCL Construction, one of the largest general contractors in North America, created its “Agile” division about three years ago to move into the modular construction industry. MBI wanted to find out what drove PCL to this decision.
According to Terry Olynyk, Director of Business Development for PCL Construction, “The world of construction is rapidly moving towards the digital age and with that [so is] industrialized construction. PCL did not want to stay on the sidelines while this paradigm shift is occurring and wanted to lead the market by being the first fully integrated general contractor with its own modular factory.”
PCL’s strategy when approaching a project is to first ask how much of the project can be built offsite. “Our end goal is to target scopes that reduce the project critical path and gain us valuable time,” Olynyk said. He continued, “Another consideration is the complexity of the scope and challenges we have with hours of work, work location, available sub-trades to perform the work, geographical area. We then assess these constraints against our ability to ship the volumetric spaces and the associated costs. With advanced digital tools combined virtual models we are getting better at decoupling spaces and finding advantages with modular.” Anthony Zarilli’s transition took place more than 15 years ago while building homes in New Jersey. According to Zarrilli, he knew modular home building had the potential to change the future of new home construction when he first started researching it.
It all started when Zarrilli, while working alongside his father constructing custom “stick-built” houses, saw an article about modular homes which piqued his interest. After visiting several modular plants and receiving approval to build, he ordered his first modular home. Zarrilli set the home in Point Pleasant, New Jersey by himself, and because his real estate agent wasn’t quite sure how to market a modular home, he decided to sell it himself.
Once the home sold, Zarrilli repeated the process, but this time in Point Pleasant Beach. While working on that project, people started to take notice. Before he knew it, Zarrilli was being asked to build modular homes for others.
“I went from building four homes per year to eight to 12 and it just kept on growing from there,” he said. “That’s really how it all started.” Today, Zarrilli Homes is expanding into new markets such as multifamily.
Making the move to modular construction is not without some challenges. Every aspect of the construction industry is considered from the perspective that the materials and labor show up on a specific site and work begins there. Moving construction to an offsite location requires greater coordination and communication among all parties. Everything from insurance to legal consideration to payment schedules need to be discussed and agreed upon in in advance.
How Owner/Developers Can Best Get Started with Modular Construction w/ R & S Tavares Associates
In this episode of MBI's Inside Modular podcast, Pedro Tavares and Anthony Gude of R & S Tavares Associates share best practices for owner/developers looking to incorporate modular construction into their upcoming projects.
MBI is actively working with other organizations to address many of these site related barriers, including providing more resources in the building codes, a design guideline for architects, and a standard contractual language between general contractors and modular manufacturers.
But for many contractors, it’s simply a matter of time before this process is mainstream. Olynyk sums it up this way, “design tools and materials have greatly advanced over the past 20 years. The construction industry has been building the same for over 100 years and is about to change. A significant skilled labor decline has started in North America coupled with the rising cost of labor and productivity falling. The construction industry will soon be forced to look at alternatives that will keep the projects on track. We will soon realize a cost shift where onsite “stick-built” becomes more expensive than modular construction. Lack of construction labor, quality concerns, and project certainty with modular solutions will force the construction industry into a long overdue change.”
Other Contractors Making the Leap
Chicago-based Skender recently announced plans to open a new Skender Manufacturing facility that will assemble modular building parts for senior housing, multifamily, healthcare, and other commercial buildings in the Windy City. Manufacturing will begin as soon as this November.
Baltimore-based general contractor Whiting-Turner has a history of delivering successful modular projects including student housing and hotels. The company touts “prefab and modular” as part of their corporate expertise now. According to their website, “Prefabrication of building systems and components is made possible by the accuracy of the digital submission process. This saves costly rework; reduces waste, installation time and onsite labor; and significantly enhances quality and safety.”
This article originally appeared in the Modular Advantage Magazine - Fourth Quarter 2018 released in November 2018.
More from Modular Advantage
The city of Malmö in southern Sweden is set to welcome a new student housing project Unity Malmö, comprised of 5 building blocks, 450 micro-living apartments, where Forta PRO delivered 269 modules, total of 9,671.9 m2.
Using the latest advances in building science and prefabrication,
CertainTeed developed these wall, floor, ceiling, and roof panel assemblies to meet the needs of builders and developers wanting to build higher-performing
DMDmodular has recently achieved a significant milestone by successfully completing a relevant
energy-efficient housing project, fully financed by EU funds, that tackles the industry’s most pressing challenges.
homeD’s mission is to alleviate homelessness and in British Columbia and they’ve developed unique modular housing products to that end. The company also embraces a strong social justice ethic, providing solutions for marginalized communities who face housing challenges, and is aligned with the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals.
Forta PRO, a modular building manufacturer in Latvia, recently partnered with Marriott to create a modular hotel room based on their current design, Moxy. The two connected in Copenhagen in 2019, when Marriott expressed an interest in creating a mock-up to show investors the quality available through modular construction techniques. The stand-alone room is currently located in Frankfurt and is available for investors to visit.
South America is a mining powerhouse, producing a substantial amount of the world’s silver, copper, tin, zinc, lithium, and nickel, and the mining industry requires a substantial amount of infrastructure to operate. That infrastructure includes workforce housing and office space that modular builders such as PROMET provide.
On February 6, 2023, a 7.8 magnitude earthquake rocked southern and central Turkey, killing over 2,300 people and injuring 10,000 more. DORCE responded with the force of its huge production capacity, dedicating all their abilities to producing emergency houses for those displaced by the disaster with help from AFAD (Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency of Turkish Republic).
The Envelope Insulation Design Regarding Material Alteration Compatibility in Blast-Resistant Modular Buildings
BRM envelope insulation configuration has impacts on construction schedule time, potential redesign workload, and market competitiveness, which are all critical to the success of a BRM project.
With over 2,300 damaged or destroyed schools, the potential for modular construction as part of the rebuilding effort is huge. In fact, mayors from several cities asked me about this exact issue when I visited in May. And, of course, the needs for medical clinics and housing are greater than ever.
There is a popular narrative indicating that the world is now splintering after a period of coming together. For decades, the world seemed destined to become a unified production unit. Dozens of free trade agreements, the expansion of World Trade Organization (WTO) membership, and import/export data suggested that national boundaries were falling, at least with respect to the movement of goods, including productive construction inputs.