Industrializing Modular Construction With Pop-Up Factories
Xavier Jaffray is the founder and president of LECO, a modular construction company in France. The Leco group specializes in the design and construction - in an industrial environment - of carbon-free buildings exclusively based on wood.
Before Xavier Jaffray launched LECO, a modular construction company, in France in 2013, he held management positions in both Toyota and Bic factories. He’d seen industrialized manufacturing up close. When he began researching the construction industry, he found that the companies that manufacture components for buildings — such as roof trusses, wall panels, and windows — are industrialized, but there was no industrialization in design and construction.
“Industrialization is based on the idea of manufacturing the same product over and over again, every day,” Jaffray says. Conventional construction doesn’t repeatedly produce the same product, so it doesn’t gain the efficiencies of industrialization. Part of the problem is that construction is necessarily localized and project-based. A social housing project here, a student dorm project there, a hotel project somewhere else.
Just because modular construction takes place in a factory, that by itself doesn’t mean it’s industrialized. “A real estate company might order 200 identical modules. But 200 units is not a mass-produced product,” Jaffray says.
A constant stream of identical products is typical of industrial manufacturing. When a factory isn’t producing anything, it continues to incur overheads, which is clearly inefficient. So, a challenge for modular construction companies is to eliminate factory overheads between projects. One way to do this is to have constant demand so there are no gaps between projects. This is ideal, but it’s not something a company can control. Another way is by eliminating the factory when there’s no demand. This is the route LECO has taken.
Going Local with Pop-Up Factories
“The construction market requires agility,” says Jaffray. That is, construction companies need to adapt quickly to the location and volume of demand, without incurring overhead when there’s no demand for the product. Jaffray’s solution is novel. He uses what we might call ‘pop-up’ factories or what he sometimes calls ‘flying’ or ‘rocket’ factories near the project sites. LECO rents a large open space in a building, such as a warehouse or exhibition hall, to use as a factory. If there’s enough demand for LECO modules in the area, then the factory may continue to operate for two, five, ten years, or more. If there’s no demand, the factory closes — eliminating overheads. For as long as the factory is open, it’s constantly producing modules.
“It doesn’t make economic sense to have a big, permanent factory producing modules in one location and then transporting them long distances,” Jaffray says. LECO ships modules up to a distance of only 100 kilometers. LECO subcontracts with local companies on each project to transport the modules, lay the foundation, and set the modules in place. Most of the suppliers are also in the same area. They also transport the biggest modules they can each time — 5 meters wide and 20 meters long. “We’ve learned that it makes economic sense to deliver the maximum value on every truck trip.”
Eliminating overheads when a project isn’t going through means that LECO has been able to lower costs so that their timber modular construction is cheaper, as well as faster, than both conventional concrete or timber construction.
“Our first project using a temporary factory was a school for 600 students. It took three months in the warehouse-factory, and one month on the site to complete.”
Since then, LECO has opened seven temporary factories in France. Just as important as the temporary factories is the simple assembly process that can be taught quickly to unskilled local workers.
Labor and Logistics
For maximum efficiency, LECO needs to be able to get people working in the temporary factories quickly. They also need to draw from the pool of labor local to each factory. This means they can’t rely on being able to find skilled workers. Having to rely on unskilled labor requires an assembly process that is very simple and quick to learn. LECO’s factories do not cut the wood for their modules (eliminating the need for cutting machines and skilled workers to operate them). The pre-cut wood is delivered to LECO’s temporary factories for assembly.
Having a number of temporary factories, instead of one permanent one, creates logistical supply chain challenges. To address these challenges, LECO formed a dedicated supply chain division. LECO is a group of four companies, each of which has a different function: supply chain; employee training; engineering; and signing the contract with the client.
“Our supply chain company buys the wood and finds a company in the vicinity of the project who can cut it,” Jaffray explains. “We get the wood delivered to that company, and give them the files they need for their cutting machines. Then, the cut pieces are delivered to our temporary factory for assembly.”
Like McDonald's
Jaffray wants LECO to grow without becoming a huge company with high overhead. The way they’re doing this is by selling LECO licenses. “For those who buy a LECO license, we provide the engineering, we deliver the pre-cut components, and we train the employees. But they sign the contracts with their clients and employees, and they arrange for delivery and installation of the modules.”
LECO currently has two licensees in Germany and is working on getting licensees in the UK and the US. “I’m looking for people in the US who want to change the world,” Jaffray says with a laugh.
He compares his licensing business model to McDonald’s franchising. McDonald’s doesn’t have a huge factory where it manufactures Bic Macs to ship long distances to every McDonald’s restaurant. “McDonald’s franchisees hire unskilled workers locally at each restaurant. Those workers make the same products in all the different locations, using a simple process, with ingredients from the local supply chain. The restaurants in all their locations then serve the exact same products,” Jaffray says.
Recent and Upcoming Projects
Last year, in the heart of Paris, LECO built a three-story student dormitory on top of an existing three-story building. “With 400 people living within 100 meters of the construction site, there were concerns about construction noise over a long period,” Jaffray says. But LECO completed the project quickly and quietly.
For a month and a half, an exhibition hall in the north of Paris wasn’t holding any events. “So we rented the space for that period between two exhibition events,” Jaffray explains. “We spent four nights placing the modules and the maximum noise we made was briefly 80 decibels.” (According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 80 decibels is the same volume as city traffic from inside a car, and is significantly quieter than a motorcycle.)
For the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris, LECO will rent space from a large trade show company to build accommodation for 100 athletes. It’ll be needed for only two months. Like all LECO modules, they can be moved afterwards and be used for other purposes.
Jaffray explains that being able to relocate buildings is a more sustainable and economical solution than building new facilities when others are under-used. For example, an area may no longer need an elementary school building, but it now needs accommodation for college students. So instead of a building standing empty or under-used at the elementary school and building new college accommodation, the building can be relocated from the elementary school to the college.
“Relocatability is especially important for social housing,” Jaffray explains. “It’s easier and quicker to get approval if the housing is permitted for a limited period of time, eight years say, rather than permanently. That means that people can be housed sooner, but still in high quality buildings.”
About the Author: Zena Ryder is a freelance writer, specializing in writing about construction and for construction companies. You can find her at Zena, Freelance Writer or on LinkedIn.
More from Modular Advantage
Stacking Up: How Vision Modular is Helping Take Modular Construction to New Heights
VMS’ latest modular project in London’s Canary Wharf, dubbed Marsh Wall, will sit among many of the city’s iconic, high-rise buildings.
Vertical Engineering: Inside the World’s Tallest Modular Building with MJH Structural Engineers’ Michael Hough
“101 George Street has moved modular into the realm of skyscrapers and is achieving recognition alongside some of the world’s most amazing new tall buildings,” says Michael Hough.
Designing for a Sustainable—and Modular—Future
A conversation with Stuart Cameron,
Managing Director and MMC Lead at SCMS Associates/The HIve Group, about the current state of modular and offsite construction in the UK.
The Rapid Rise of Affordable Modular Housing in Canada
Canada’s Rapid Housing Initiative represents a huge success for the modular construction industry, and MBI members are building modular multifamily homes fast. Here are some examples.
Seeing the Potential for Modular Construction in Colombia
Founded in 1983, Constructora Bolivar specializes in the design, construction, project management, and sales of single family and multi-residential homes across the Colombian social strata. Now it’s laying the groundwork for the country’s modular construction industry.
Modular Building Poised for Takeoff Globally
That modular building hasn’t already gained more U.S. market share is a source of bewilderment to many. Though the technology has been around for more than 70 years, modular building in the U.S. has never gained as solid a foothold as it has in other societies. But it’s time may finally be here.
Wilmot Modular: Always Willing to Help Out
Mike Wilmot, president of Wilmot Modular in Maryland, shares his experience responding to natural disasters and explains his company’s Rapid Response Program.
The Quick Response to Hurricane Katrina
Jane Conkin, owner of Quick Buildings Modular, recalls how her company provided much-needed modular buildings after Hurricane Katrina.
In Rough Times, Black Diamond Shines
Black Diamond CEO Trevor Haynes talks about the disasters his company has helped with and how disaster response is more than the “nuts and bolts” of transporting assets.
A Village Inspires a New Modular Emergency Housing Concept
These emergency housing modules, designed by Oregon’s MODS, have been designed so they don’t require highly skilled labor to build them — which opens up employment opportunities for the future residents of the buildings.