Skip to content

MBI Secures NY Governor Veto On Bill Targeting Modular Industry

Under the just-vetoed New York law, modular building projects destines for New York City would have been required to be supervised by NYC-licensed professionals. Such burdens would have severely limited the potential for modular in the city.

In June 2022, the New York legislative session ended with a back room political deal to pass Senate bill S4738-A. The bill would require that all electrical, plumbing, and fire suppression work performed during off-site assembly of modular units for buildings of six or more stories in New York City be performed by “applicable licensees” licensed by the New York City Department of Buildings. In other words, no matter where in the world these modules were produced, a NYC-licensed professional would have to supervise the work.

Understanding the severe impact such a rule would have on future modular projects in NYC, the Modular Building Institute and its coalition partners, which included the New York City Mayor’s office, New York State Association for Affordable Housing, and the Consulate General of Canada, never stopped work to defeat this unnecessary bill. MBI led numerous calls with Governor Hochul’s Lead Counsel to share its concerns and to ask the Governor for a veto.

After six months of lobbying with the Governor and the New York City Mayor’s office, Governor Hochul officially vetoed the bill on December 29, 2022. Not only did she veto the bill, but her message to the legislature also included all the message points MBI had shared with her office.

Governor Hochul's comments are below:

This bill is unnecessary because modular construction must already comply with the New York City Building Code, and NYC DOB must inspect and approve modular unit housing in order to issue a certificate of occupancy. The bill also provides no pathway for out-of-state contractors to become licensed to perform the work covered by the bill.

Moreover, the requirements to use licensees for all plumbing, electrical, and fire suppression work offsite and for installation and connection work onsite will significantly increase the cost of constructing modular units, hindering an important resource for the development of much-needed multifamily and affordable housing in New York City, and this is at odds with my administration's commitment to addressing our critical housing needs.

For these reasons, I am constrained to veto this bill.

This bill is disapproved.                     


“This is a great win for the modular industry in New York," said MBI Government Affairs Director, Jon Hannah-Spacagna, "and will also provide a precedent for future unnecessary legislative actions by the legislature regarding modular construction.”

MBI's executive director, Tom Hardiman, CAE, was quick to credit MBI's success to its long-running regulatory relief program. "This win for the industry is a perfect example of why MBI has its Seals Program," said Hardiman. "Funds from the Seals Program are used to hire local professionals to help defeat anti-industry bills like this one. We cannot allow lawmakers and bureaucrats to start chipping away at the gains we’ve made over the past several years.

Additional Government Affairs Articles

MBI Members Provide Testimony to White House Regarding Concerns of Davis-Bacon Act Expansion

On a recent call with the White House’s Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA), several MBI members provided testimony about the potential impact expanding the Davis-Bacon Act would have on their company and the industry.

Read Complete Article
The Davis Bacon Act was intended for traditional construction and is ill-suited for more modern modular construction. methods.

What is the Davis-Bacon Act and How Does it Affect Modular Construction?

Adopted in 1941, the Davis-Bacon Act was written long before the modular construction industry gained momentum. Now, the US Dept. of Labor is considering applying the law in ways that will seriously curtail the use of modular construction for federal and state projects.

Read Complete Article

MBI Solves Relocatable Building Code Issues in Atlanta

A large fleet owner member of MBI was recently delayed in Georgia due to the state’s confusion over the details of the International Building Code. According to the company’s regional general manager, “The feedback we got was, ‘Your plans are not up to date, you need to bring them up to code.’”

Here’s how MBI was able to correct the state’s misunderstanding.

Read Complete Article

MBI Helps Kick-Start Stalled Plan Review Process

Modular projects in Washington State had ground to a halt. Plan review lead times began stretching into six, eight, even twelve weeks. “Over the summer of 2021, it was getting even longer than that,” says Alan Rasmussen of Modern Building Systems. “By the fall and winter of 2021, reviews were taking 24 weeks.”

Here’s how MBI was able to get things moving again.

Read Complete Article