By the Numbers
Assessing MBI Member Training, Professional Development & Workforce Needs
Heather Packard is the Workforce & Professional Development Director for the Modular Building Institute
As part of MBI’s continuing efforts to expand the footprint of the commercial modular construction industry, we launched an intelligence gathering process in mid-September 2023 to collect information on member companies’ challenges and needs with respect to training, professional development, and workforce. The purpose of this process was to identify critical needs to support development of a near- and long-term strategy to address these needs.
Intelligence Gathering Process
The intelligence gathering process included two phases: a qualitative phase consisting of one-on-one conversations with representative member companies and a quantitative phase consisting of a survey instrument distributed to all MBI contacts.
To ensure a representative set of data for the first, qualitative, phase, conversations were held across member company types including manufacturers (5 direct and 3 wholesale), dealers/fleet owners (3), owners/developers (2), contractors/builders (3), design professionals (3), suppliers of services (1), and suppliers of materials (2).
This phase probed challenges member companies are experiencing at an industry-wide, company-specific, and partner-specific level as well as ideas on how MBI could support attracting new entrants to our industry along with training and professional development opportunities for staff.
Visualized results from one question of MBI's Workforce and Professional Development survey from September 2023.
Qualitative Outcomes
Challenges at an industry-wide level uncovered during the qualitative phase included labor – limited supply of skilled tradespeople as well as experienced architects, engineers, and project managers – along with a lack of stakeholder awareness of modular capabilities, including clients, architects, and financial institutions.
Company-specific challenges also included labor – difficulties in attracting tradespeople, backfilling at mid and senior levels, and small talent pools for design, drafting, estimating, and purchasing – along with market supply and demand and finding new areas of growth.
Partner-specific challenges uncovered insufficient production capacity at the manufacturer level and a need for increased awareness and education amongst stakeholders including developers, lenders, building inspectors, general contractors, and clients.
Training and professional development ideas discussed included opportunities to leverage Introduction to Commercial Modular Construction for employee on-boarding and developing training for commercial modular set and install staff, sales staff, project management staff, and market-facing individuals. The one-on-one conversations also uncovered a need for building code-based training and refreshers for MBI member companies, government officials, and financial institutions.
Ideas for attracting new entrants centered on increasing youth awareness of the commercial modular construction industry’s opportunities and advantages over traditional construction. These discussions included potential outreach and engagement opportunities directed towards high-school level groups promoting trades and with vocational technology centers in an effort towards increasing the future talent pipeline for labor and trades. Outreach and engagement with universities offering a construction-related degree was another hallmark of these conversations, with a goal towards increasing university program curriculum focus on modular in the hope that this could lead to better-trained and more well-rounded future designers, architects, engineers, and project managers.
Quantitative Phase
We used a survey instrument for the second, quantitative, phase, which was distributed to all MBI contacts. To date, we have received responses from 68 unique organizations across all MBI membership categories and affiliations, a roughly 12% response rate. The survey instrument addressed the following topics:
- Estimated workforce needs over the next 1-3 years
- Most difficult roles to fill within the past 1-2 years
- Longest time it has taken to fill vacant roles
- Most useful recruiting methods
- Educational topics of interest
- Learning format preferences
Quantitative Outcomes: Estimated Workforce Needs
Current responses to estimated workforce needs across administrative and office professional staff demonstrate a near-term (next 1-3 years) need for the following roles:
Current responses to estimated workforce needs across labor, trades, and delivery staff demonstrate a near-term (next 1-3 years) need for the following roles:
Current responses to estimated workforce needs across safety, compliance, and quality assurance/control staff demonstrate a near-term (next 1-3 years) need for the following roles:
Quantitative Outcomes: Most Difficult Roles to Fill, Longest Time to Fill Vacant Roles, and Most Useful Recruiting Methods
The most difficult roles to fill within the last 1-2 years echoed the small talent pools uncovered in the first, qualitative, phase, and included tradespeople of all types, general and skilled labor, carpenters/framers, drywall finishers, experienced production and plant workers, architects, designers, engineers, and project managers – with experience in modular – as well as drafters, BIM experts/managers, sales professionals, customer service, and estimators.
Responses to the longest time to fill vacant roles further demonstrate the talent shortage our industry is experiencing. Roles for CAD operators and designers, electricians, plumbers, welders, and quality control staff were reported to take greater than 1 year to 2 years to fill.
Members reported word of mouth and referrals from current employees as the most useful recruiting method, followed closely by social media efforts and job boards (typically Indeed for labor and trades). The full list of recruiting methods, their current rankings, and responses to “other, please specify” is below.
Quantitative Outcomes: Topics of Interest and Learning Format Preferences
In terms of learning topics of interest, members reported an interest in regulatory topics including building codes and permitting, best practices in the industry, design and engineering, research and innovation, project scoping, execution and management, planning for growth and expansion, and quality assurance and control. The full list of learning topics of interest and their current rankings is below.
Lastly, members expressed a preference for live webinars, live in-person events, video recordings with slides and transcripts, and self-paced online courses. The full list of learning formats and their current rankings is below.
Make Your Voice Heard
The survey instrument will remain open so that we can continue to collect member needs and preferences and take these into account for further strategy development and execution. Please visit MBI's online survey and make your voice heard!
If you have any questions about the process or have other feedback or suggestions for MBI to consider, please contact Heather Packard, Professional & Workforce Development Director, at heather@modular.org.
More from Modular Advantage
T.R. Arnold: The Art of Third-Party Inspections
T.R. Arnold (TRA), a third-party inspection company in Elkhart, Indiana, contracts with modular manufacturers across the US. Manufacturers register with each state to which they intend to send their modules and may be required to hire a third-party inspection company.
Creating an ‘Ecosystem for Innovation:’ 50+ Years of Modular Construction Oversight in Virginia
Virginia’s modular building program began in 1973, with the implementation of the Virginia Industrialized Building Unit and Mobile Home Safety Regulations. Now it’s leading the country in modular code adoption.
Understanding Thermal Barriers Compliance Methods & Emerging NFPA-275 Foam Plastic Technologies
New fire barrier technologies are improving total costs and margins in major areas of construction, such as commercial, government, union and prevailing wage projects. These benefits translate into other large fringe areas, such as agriculture, commercial cold storage facilities, grow houses, outbuildings, military and aviation hangars.
Financing the Future of Modular Construction: How Better Capital Strategies Can Help the Industry Scale
The future of construction will not be solved by one product, one lender, or one financing model. It will be solved by matching the right project with the right capital strategy.
Building Customized Technical Containers for Data Centers and the Energy Sector
Modern data centers must not only be highly efficient but also flexible and secure. One answer to these core challenges is modular data centers housed in containers.
Printing the Future of Modular Construction
For the modular and offsite construction industry, 3D concrete printing should not be viewed as a competing construction method. It should be understood as a potential expansion of the industrialized construction toolkit.
Quality Control for Modular Houses Manufactured in Asia
In modular construction, prevention is far cheaper than correction. A good inspection plan protects the buyer, supports the supplier, and helps the final project succeed.
Housing Without Borders: Go Global with Haskell Modular Solutions
With the capacity to service over 15 diverse markets across multiple continents, Haskell is the reliable choice for our 80% repeat client base no matter how their needs evolve. So, when a longstanding client—typically known for their large-scale, institutional buildings—engaged Haskell with a very different need—multinational
housing projects—Haskell knew exactly what approach to take.
ProSet Co-founder Shares Expertise to Help Ensure Safe and Secure Modular Connections in Colorado
ProSet co-founder Matt Mitchell created and teaches an 8-hour course, based on Colorado’s modular installation regulations.
Women in Construction – Reflections on a Journey, Then and Now
From industry veteran Laurie Robert, a retrospective for women who are thinking about entering the modular construction industry or are looking to elevate their current position into leadership.